(Project of the Kajima Institute of International Peace)
Does Economic Interdependence not Encourage Collaboration? ―Thinking Japan-China Relations from an Economic Perspective―
Ph.D., Toyo University
The liberal school of international relations argues that increased economic interdependence between countries reduces the chances of them engaging in conflict. The notion that economic interdependence encourages international collaboration is nothing new (Russett & Oneal 2001). As trade ties deepen, any conflict-induced interruption in commercial activity will have higher costs, states have an added incentive to avoid military confrontation.
However, deepening economic interdependence does not appear to have stabilized Japan-China relations. Japan-China relations have seriously deteriorated over the Senkaku / Diaoyu issue since 2012, adversely affecting the activities of Japanese companies in the Chinese market. Does this mean that economic ties cannot encourage a peaceful relationship between Japan and China?
This paper considers such a question by viewing the Japan-China economic relationship in a broader context that goes beyond bilateral interdependence. The first section overviews changes in Japan-China economic relations. Taking this in mind, the second section examines influences of changes in economic relations on political relations. The conclusion of this paper is that bilateral economic ties cannot automatically lead to a peaceful relationship.
Honeymoon between Japan and China
Japan and China were indispensable trading partners even before the 1972 normalization of diplomatic ties. Japan was already China's largest trade partner in 1972, accounting for 12% of China's exports and 22% of imports (NBSC 1981). Especially after Deng Xiaoping came back to power in the late 1970s, China recognized Japan as the most important provider of funds and technology for its Reform and Open-up Policy.1 On the other hand, also for Japan, China had been an important economic partner as a potential huge market that complements the U.S. and Europe, as well as a supply source of resources ever since the 1970s. In short, both Japan and China wanted to strengthen bilateral economic tie at that time.
Economic ties have deepened significantly over the past four decades. For example, the volume of Japan-China bilateral trade between 1988 and 2016 expanded more than 10 times. Direct investment from Japan to China also jumped from 230 million yen in 1991 to 8.6 billion yen in 2016. Along with the expansion of trade, the number of visitors also grew. While 170,000 Japanese traveled to China in 1980, the figure in 2015 was 2.5 million. And the number of Chinese visiting Japan swelled from a mere 20,000 in 1980 to 6.4 million in 2016.
Changes in Relative Economic Importance
Economic relations between Japan and China have changed in the first decade of the 2000s. Figure 1 shows the shares of China's trade by country/region over a 60-year period from 1950 to 2011. As the graph shows, Japan has been claiming a smaller share of China's total trade since the late 1980s, though it remained the biggest trading partner until 2004, when it was overtaken by the United States. In terms of exports, Japan was surpassed by the Association of Southeast Asian Nations in 2009 and now represents only the fifth largest market for Chinese goods. And as for imports, Japan is now China's third-biggest partner, falling behind the European Union in 2011 and ASEAN in 2012.
For Japan, by contrast, China's economic importance had been rising dramatically until very recently. As is clear from Figure 2, the share claimed by China in Japan's total trade grew steadily from the mid-1990s, eventually topping the United States in 2007. The country is now Japan's biggest trading partner, accounting for 20% of total trade value.
However, China's economic importance is declining in the last couple of years. For example, the volume of Japan's export to China has been decreasing since the second half of 2011, and the United States once again replaced China as Japan's largest exporting market in the first half of 2013. As for foreign direct investment from Japan, the volume toward Southeast Asia has always exceeded the volume toward China since 2009. In 2013, Japan's investment to Southeast Asia doubled over the previous year. On the other hand, Japan's investment to China decreased by approximately 30% over the same period. The former investment was almost twice of the latter one in volume.
Figure 1. China's Foreign Trade by Country, 1950–2011
Figure 2. Japan's Foreign Trade by Country, 1950–2011
Negative Effect on the Political Relations
It seems that the change in Japan-China economic relations had a negative effect on the bilateral political relations. One reason that economic ties remained relatively unscathed by periods of political tension in the postwar era—such as the years of "cold politics and a hot economy" in the early 2000s, when Jun'ichiro Koizumi was prime minister—was because there was real demand in the private sector for the goods that each side was able to supply. The two governments, moreover, did not want to see the political dimension of the relationship dampen the robust economic ties. However, both Tokyo and Beijing are likely to lose the motivation to quickly and harmoniously improve the deteriorated political relations, since they no longer put the top priority on strengthening economic ties between the two countries.
Moreover, Beijing seems to have a biased view that the Japanese economy needs China more than vice versa. Based on this biased view, Beijing may be tempted to take advantage of the asymmetrical trade relationship to pressure Japan into making political concessions.2 For example, following the trawler collision incident near the Senkaku Islands in 2010, media reports noted that China restricted exports of rare earths to Japan.3 There were also reports that Chinese customs inspections for imports from Japan were delayed in the wake of Senkaku's nationalization.4 Unfortunately for Beijing, Tokyo made no compromise even facing the economic sanctions.
Is it not true that economic ties can encourage peace among countries? A lesson from recent Japan-China relations is that bilateral economic ties cannot automatically lead to a peaceful relationship. It is important to carefully look at the recent trend of changes in the relative degree of economic importance rather than in the bilateral absolute volume of economic transactions.
A man won't feed bait to a fish he's caught. When people want to make the relationship tighter, they can be gentle and patient. Once the relationship becomes deep and stable, however, people often lose enthusiasm for maintaining the relationship. Until they once again realize the importance of their ties, they may not stop quarreling. Such quarrels might, in some cases, result in a fierce fight in some cases.
Similarly once the economic interdependence becomes deep and stable, countries may lose enthusiasm for maintaining the relationship. Until they once again realize the importance of their ties, they may not stop diplomatic quarrels. Such rivalries might further serve to deteriorate bilateral relations and in some cases result in a fierce fight.
Until recently, both Japan and China wanted to strengthen bilateral economic ties. On the one hand, China recognized Japan as the most important provider of funds and technology for its Reform and Opening-up Policy. On the other hand, also for Japan, China had been an important economic partner as a potential huge market as well as a supplier of resources. Reflecting the economic honeymoon, the two governments did not want to see the political dimension of the relationship dampen the robust economic ties. Today, however, both Tokyo and Beijing seem to lose the enthusiasm to quickly and harmoniously improve the deteriorated political relations, since they no longer put a top priority on strengthening economic ties between the two countries.
The economic honeymoon in the 1970s is unlikely to come back. It is more possible that political confrontations over the Senkaku Islands and other historical issues will continuously come up between Tokyo and Beijing. Even under this situation, we should not forget the fact that any economic sanctions between Japan and China would likely be a double-edged sword. Once the deeply interdependent economic transactions are restricted by political confrontation between Japan and China, it could hurt both economies.
Deteriorating political relations should not affect the interdependent economic relations. The whole Japan-China relations could become stuck if we every time allow the political tensions between the governments to damage transactions and communications in the private sector. It is important for Tokyo and Beijing to share this lesson as a principle. And, researchers should insist on stable economic transactions and active private communication even when the governments are involved in political confrontations.
- Bruce Russett and John Oneal. (2001). Triangulating Peace: Democracy, Interdependence, and International Organizations. Norton.
- JETRO (Japan External Trade Organization). (2013). Survey of Japanese-Affiliated Companies in Asia and Oceania. http://www.jetro.go.jp/en/reports/survey/pdf/2013_12_27_biz.pdf.
- MRI (Mizuho Research Institute). (2014). Questionnaire Survey of Japanese Corporate Enterprises Regarding Business in Asia as of February 2014. http://www.mizuho-ri.co.jp/publication/research/pdf/report/report14-0515.pdf. (English summary: http://www.mizuho-ri.co.jp/publication/research/pdf/eo/MEA140724.pdf )
- NBSC (National Bureau of Statistics of China). (1981) China Statistical Yearbook, 1981.
- Robert Gilpin. (1987). The Political Economy of International Relations, Princeton University Press.
- August 2019: Several Perspectives on the Korean Peninsula Issue--- The Deteriorating Japan-South Korea Relationship and the Uncertain Denuclearization of North Korea --- By Masahiro Akiyama Chairman, the SSDP
- July 2019, "An Outlook on the Denuclearization of North Korea--- What is the Stance of North Korea?---", Junya Nishino, Professor, Keio University
- July 2019, "An Outlook on the Denuclearization of North Korea --- How will the US move?", Narushige Michishita, Vice President, National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies
- July 2019, "Discussion on Denuclearization of North Korea", SSDP Discussion Meeting on May 8, 2019
- May 2019: "Current Status and Prospects of South Korea and Japan's Frictions over History: How to address the Judicial Problems", Masao Okonogi, Professor Emeritus, Keio University
- May 2019: "South Korea and Japan's Frictions over History" (Comments), Junya Nishino, Professor, Keio University
- May 2019: Japan and South Korea Relationships (Question & Answer)
- March 2019: "The Present State and Prospects of the Indian Economy and Economic Policies" written by Koji Kobayashi, Senior Economist Mizuho Research Institute Ltd.
- March 2019: "The "Modi diplomacy" in the History of Indian diplomacy--- Departure from or maintenance of the traditional diplomacy? ---" written by Toru Ito, The National Defense Academy of Japan
- February 2019: Dynamics of Indian Politics and the 2019 General Elections, written by Chiharu Takenaka, Professor of Rikkyo University
- February 2019: "Cooperative Strategy" to Realize "Competitive Strategy"--- The composite structure of Japan's "Free and Open Indo-Pacific" strategy (vision) ---, written by Matake Kamiya, Professor at The National Defense Academy of Japan
- January 2019:, A paper, "How will the US midterm elections results affect the Trump administration's foreign policy for 2019?" written by Tsuneo Watanabe, Senior Fellow, the Sasakawa Peace Foundation
- January 2019:, A paper, "The Present and Future of the International Trade Order" , written by Akihiko Tamura, Professor, National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies
- December 2018: The US-China Competition and Japan, written by Ryo Sahashi, Professor at Kanagawa University
- December 2018: An Outlook for the US-China Trade War―What makes the two economically interdependent superpowers confront each other?―, written by Takashi Sekiyama, Associate professor at Toyo University
- September 2018: Proposal, "The Denuclearization of North Korea and the Restoration of Peace in the Korean Peninsula― Correct Perceptions and Eight Proposals on Japan's North Korea Diplomacy－" edited by the Society of Security and Diplomatic Policy Studies
- September 2018: "The Taiwan Policy of the Xi Jinping Administration in its Second Term: An Outlook on Cross-Strait Relations in the New Era" written by Yasuhiro Matsuda, Professor of the Tokyo University
- July 2018: "The EU States and Russia on North Korea Issues- Expansion of Influence through Diplomacy: Attempts and Limitations -" lectured by Yuichi Hosoya, Professor of Keio University
- "An Assessment of the US-North Korea Summit and an Outlook for the Future of the Korean Peninsula" lectured by Junya Nishino, Professor of Keio University
- "Korean Peninsula Issue and Japan's Future Security Policy" written by Hideshi Tokuchi, Senior Fellow of National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies
- July 2018: "US North Korea policy affected by personnel changes in the Trump administration" lectured by Tsuneo Watanabe, Senior Fellow of the Sasakawa Peace Foundation.
- "China-North Korea relationship under Xi Jinping" lectured by Shin Kawashima, Professor of the Tokyo University.
- "North Korean Denuclearization and Russia" lectured by Nobuo Shimotomai, Professor of the Hosei University.
- March 2018: "The Network Hegemony Theory for a Security Architecture in The Asia Pacific Region" lectured by Masahiro Akiyama, Chairman, the Society of Security and Diplomatic Policy Studies
- January 2018: "A Destabilized Middle East" lectured by Koichiro Tanaka, Professor, Keio University
- December 2017: "Problems in Sino-Japanese Relations, 1992-2042" lectured by Ezra F. Vogel, Professor of the Social Sciences Emeritus at Harvard University
- November 2017: "The Future of the Asia-Pacific Region" written by Yoriko Kawaguchi, Fellow, the Meiji Institute for Global Affairs, Former Minister Foreign Affairs
- October 2017: "A New Trend in India's Foreign Policy and Japan" Written by HIROSE,Takako, Professor, Senshu University
- August 2017: "The Shocks that shook the Transatlantic World and their Implication for Japan's Foreign Policy" written by HOSOYA, Yuichi, Professor, Keio University
- August 2017: "Does Economic Interdependence not Encourage Collaboration? ―Thinking Japan-China Relations from an Economic Perspective―" written by Takashi SEKIYAMA, Ph.D., Toyo University
- July 2017: Proposal article "The Trump Administration's Impact on the Cross-Strait Relations" written by Yasuhiro Matsuda, Ph.D.
- June 2017: Proposal article "The outlook for the relationship between two great powers and implications for Japanese diplomacy" written by Professor Shin Kawashima
- May 2017: (Emergency Proposal) Facing the Inconvenient Truth: Re-examining Policy for Peace and Denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula (Chief author, Masao Okonogi)
- March 2017: "Economic Influences of the Trump Administration" written by Professor Motoshige Ito
- February, 2017: Proposal article "Trump's Foreign and Security Policy - Unpredictable President, Realistic Secretaries - " written by Mr. Tsuneo Watanabe is posted on the website of SSDP.
- December, 2016: Proposal article "Reconsidering North Korea Policy: How to Deal with a Nuclear Armed Divided States" written by Professor Masao Okonogi is posted on the website of SSDP.
- August 2019: Report; 2019 FUTURE CONSENSUS DIALOGUE --Sustainable Prosperity and Future of Korea-U.S.-Japan Cooperation-- By Future Consensus Institute (Yeosijae)
- June 2019: Report on India – Japan Security Dialogue 2019 by Ms. Vindu Mai Chotani, Ph.D Student, The University of Tokyo
June 2019: Four papers on Japan-India Cooperation submitted to India-Japan Security Dialogue 2019
Japan's Rationale for a Free and Open Indo-Pacific Vision
Tsuneo Watanabe, Senior Fellow, The Sasakawa Peace Foundation
The Significance and Possibilities of India-Japan Cooperation in the Concept of the Indo-Pacific
Toru ITO Associate Professor, National Defense Academy of Japan
Japan-India Defense Cooperation in the Indo-Pacific Context - Operationalizing the Security Aspect of the Indo-Pacific Vision –
Hideshi Tokuchi, Senior Fellow, National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies (GRIPS)
India-US-Japan Defense Cooperation: What's next?
Dr. Satoru Nagao, Hudson Institute
- Japan's Rationale for a Free and Open Indo-Pacific Vision
- November 2018: "The Present State of the Japanese Economy and Policy Issues" lectured by Motoshige Itoh, Professor Emeritus at the University of Tokyo.
- November 2018: "Expanding Social Security Expenses and Fiscal Reforms" lectured by Kazumasa Oguro, Professor at Hosei University.
- September 2018: "Taiwan Identity and Cross-Strait Relations and Trump's Taiwan Policy and the Future of Taiwan-US Relations-Discussion at The Second Japan-Taiwan Strategic Dialogue (June 21, 2018, Taipei)-" written by OGATA, Makoto
- September 2018: "Japan-Taiwan Dialogue 2018 Minutes", 21st June 2018, Taipei, Taiwan.
- July 2018: Report on The Second Japan – Philippines Strategic Dialogue prepared by Ms. Vindu Mai Chotani, Ph.D. Student, Graduate School of Public Policy, Tokyo University.
- May 2018: "Civilian Control "at Crisis"? – Perhaps Not, for the Case of the Field Sit-reps from SDF's South Sudan Mission" reported by Ippeita Nishida, Research Fellow, the Sasakawa Peace Foundation
- January 2018: "Fukushima, Genki？Project－Young Taiwanese volunteers introduce the facts on Fukushima's revival through documentary films－" reported by OGATA, Makoto, Former Chief of the Japan-Taiwan Exchange Association in Taipei
- December 2017: "Commemorating a Quarter Century of Dispatches of the JSDF's PKO Units: Challenges and Possibilities in the Post South Sudan" written by Takayuki Shoji, Lecturer, Nihon University
- November 2017: "19th CCP National Congress" written by Mr. Bonji Ohara, Senior Research Fellow, the Sasakawa Peace Fondation
- October 2017: "What is Japan's Role in the Indo-China border conflict?" written by Dr. NGAO,Satoru, Research Fellow, Institute for Future Engineering
- July 2017: "Overview of the Current Situation in Taiwan-" the Naturally Independent Generation" will affect the Taiwan"s politics-" written by Makoto Ogata MGE.(Ret.)
- June 2017: "Japan-U.S. Economic Dialogue" written by Mr.Takaaki Asano
- March 2017: "The Japan-Philippines Strategic Dialogue" written by Mr. Hideshi Tokuchi
- February, 2017: Current topic "The Importance of Japan's Security Role Under Trump" written by Dr. Satoru Nagao is posted on the SSDP website.
- December, 2016: Current topic "Widening Security Task: Will SDF do the Job?" written by Mr. Ippeita Nishida is posted on the SSDP website.
- August 2019: Korea-Japan Joint Seminar: FUTURE CONSENSUS DIALOGUE
- April 2019: "Security Studies (vol1 no2) April 2019"
- March 2019: A research journal "Security Studies vol1 no01" just published
- February 2019: The Denuclearization of North Korea and the Takeshima Issue
- December 2018: Former Vice Defense Minister Masahiro Akiyama's Memoirs (An Ad)
- November 2018: Participation in the Future Consensus Forum held in Beijing
- September 2018: "2018 Indo-Pacific Security Dialogue" reported by Masahiro Akiyama
- 2017 December: "The Butterfly Project-A possibility of showing a solution to the North Korea problem-"
- October 2017: Campaign on the problems with North Korea
- August 2017: A New Containment Policy Strategy
- June 2017: Korean peninsla
- March 2017: President Duterte
- February, 2017: Kazakhstan
- November, 2016: Participated in Astana Club 2016 held in Kazakhstan on November 14- 16, 2016.